The Presidential Award for Exemplary Teaching is presented to Calvin College faculty who embody the goals of forming the Christian mind and shaping the lives of students. The award is established in honor of George B. and Margaret K. Tinholt.
- 2009 - Dave Warners, Biology (read more)
- 2008 - Judith Vander Woude, Communication Arts & Sciences (read more)
- 2007 - Lee Hardy, Philosophy (read more)
- 2006 - Kenneth Bratt, Classical Languages (read more)
- 2005 - Jim Jadrich, Physics and Astronomy (read more)
- 2004 - Barbara Carvill, Germanic Languages (read more)
- 2003 - Peter De Jong, Sociology (read more)
- 2002 - Larry Nyhoff, Computer Science (read more)
- 2001 - Tom Hoeksema, Education (read more)
- 2000 - Quentin J. Schultze, Communication Arts and Sciences (read more)
- 1999 - Mary Ann Walters, English
- 1998 - Bert deVries, History
- 1997 - Martin Bolt, Psychology (read more)
- 1996 - Ronald L. Blankespoor, Chemistry
- 1995 - Paul J. Zwier, Mathematics
- 1994 - Wallace H. Bratt, German
- 1993 - Kenneth W. Kuiper, English